The fight over book of mormon geography deseret news. The purpose of saints is to present a compelling narrative of the faith and sacrifice of early latterday saints, not to weigh in subtly or otherwise on the various theories of book of mormon geography. The 21st international book of mormon evidence conference believes the book of mormon took place in north america the heartland theory, while the book of mormon central 2018 conference believes the book of mormon all took place in central america the mesoamerican theory. Some also postulate a link between ethan smith and oliver cowdery, since both men lived in poultney, vermont while smith served as the pastor of the church that oliver. Roberts took the position of examining the book of mormon from a critical perspective in order to alert the general authorities to possible future avenues of attack by critics. The problem with all theories of the book of mormons authorship that include a prolonged composition period is that there were many witnesses to at least parts of the translation process, all of whom point to a short production period.
Scholars gathered in provo, utah, to discuss their theories about where the events described in the book of mormon took place. The book of mormon clarifies the covenant nature of baptism. In this episode, laura harris hales interviews brant a. Variations of this theory only include that the text is a divinely inspired narrative, regardless of its. The discussion on book of mormon geography was getting heated. Pros, cons of book of mormon geography theories deseret news. Since they cant all be correct, obviously, some scientists are digging in the wrong place. Ex mormon behindcurtain wrote in 20 that mormons were obviously illuminati because the illuminati supposedly has a hold of the cia, and mormons are in the cia. Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading themes, theories and evidences for the book of mormon.
Who really wrote the book of mormon the critics and their. Most latterday saints are aware of a minor industry in certain religious circles in the united states devoted to refuting mormonism and. An interesting correlation with mesoamerican geographysee map below. Naturalistic explanations of the origin of the book of.
We are excited to welcome back preeminent joseph smith historian dan vogel to mormon stories podcast. The church publishes topic pages on that directly address many of the more difficult to answer questions about the book of mormon using scholarly research and historical facts. I heard him speak a few years ago on research he has done in yemen. May 27, 2010 the discussion on book of mormon geography was getting heated. It is far from perfect in its analysis but its new contributions, combined with other theories, finally paints a plausible and rational picture of the origin of the lds church. Saints and book of mormon geography church history. Sep 08, 2009 as in the ongoing theories pertaining to the geography of the book of mormon, perhaps all the three, even the gulf of darien, the tehuantepec gulf and even the honduran gulf may qualify as a narrow strip of land as described in the book of mormon.
With over a hundred other theories, these two are by far the predominant. The most intensive examination of the logic of the various and often competing or contradictory arguments against the book of mormon has been provided by hugh w. Oct 12, 2018 to our knowledge, there have been no discussions about the need to put down one theory of book of mormon geography in order to promote another. Mar 30, 2020 the book of mormon claims that moroni, a prophet, originally wrote the book and that it was translated by joseph smith. A readers guide, have attempted to move the discussion away from. Now, some critics also claim that smith gained most of his theories from a manuscript of a novel written by solomon spaulding. It is claimed that a 19th century work by ethan smith, view of the hebrews, provided source material for joseph smiths construction of the book of mormon. Like the church, book of mormon central bmc is officially geography neutral. As in the ongoing theories pertaining to the geography of the book of mormon, perhaps all the three, even the gulf of darien, the tehuantepec gulf and even the honduran gulf may qualify as a narrow strip of land as described in the book of mormon.
Foundation for ancient research and mormon studies, 1997. Book of mormon scholarship, theories, and folklore brant a. Download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc, phones or tablets. Scholars today have varying theories about the true authorship of the book of mormon, but most conclude that smith composed the book himself, possibly with the help of oliver cowdery and sidney rigdon, drawing from information and publications available in his time, including the king james bible, the wonders of nature, and view of the hebrews. The church of jesus christ of latterday saints released a statement today concerning the geography of the book of mormon in the form of a new gospel topics essay titled book of mormon geography.
The nephites mined gold and also worked copper and silver. Critical theories that sidney rigdon was a book of mormon author or coconspirator summary. Carr, president of book of mormon archaeological forum, were sending you a copy of his last article. We have sought to uphold the churchs position of neutrality on these theories. A summary of several theories of book of mormon lands in mesoamerica the contents of all bmaf publications are the sole responsibility of the individual authors and therefore do not necessarily represent the views of bmaf or the church of jesus christ of latterday saints. One of the earliest theories was that the book of mormon was based on a manuscript by solomon spaulding also spelled spalding, a fictional story about early inhabitants of america. Book of lies presents a truly unique perspective on the writing and publication of the book of mormon. What are the leading theories on what the cureloms and. Multiple witnesses had a motive to contradict their earlier testimony, but none did. As i have explained in earlier essays,2 the book of mormon writers consistently include water baptism as one element of what they call the gospel or doctrine of christ, the way whereby men can be saved in the kingdom of god 2 ne. Its time to shatter past, false assumptions and expectations of the book of mormon. Who really wrote the book of mormon the critics and. Therefore, during the past thirty years some non mormon scholars, realizing the weakness of the spaulding manuscript theory, have postulated that joseph smith might have gained some of the ideas for the book of mormon from a book by ethan smith entitled view of the hebrews, first published in vermont in 1823, with a revised, enlarged edition.
This video discusses all of the main theories critics try and point to for alternative ways the book of mormon could be produced and how these arguments fall apart when the details are explored. There is, again, the same glaring problem that i have associated with book of mormon geography. Oct 31, 2012 some mormon scholars, like grant hardy, who wrote understanding the book of mormon. Church members are asked not to teach theories about book of mormon geography in church settings but to focus instead on the book of. The book of mormons equivalent to winnie the poohs heffalumps and woozles pictured below. Some placed the nephite capital city zarahemla in mesoamerica, others in south america. Apr 09, 2019 the 21st international book of mormon evidence conference believes the book of mormon took place in north america the heartland theory, while the book of mormon central 2018 conference believes the book of mormon all took place in central america the mesoamerican theory.
Many book of mormon research projects have implications for the continuing issues surrounding the authorship of the book of mormon. For almost 200 years now, critics have been scrambling to prove that the book of mormon is nothing but a work of fiction. Get insights into latterday prophesy and learn how prophesies in the bible and other books of scripture have been fulfilled and how they may yet be fulfilled. Book of mormon evidence vs book of mormon central search isaiah. Naturalistic explanations of the origin of the book of mormon. The theory is that a spalding manuscript was stolen by sidney rigdon, who used it in collusion with joseph smith. What can stylometry tell us about book of mormon authorship. Understanding christian baptism through the book of mormon. The book of mormon geography lands and map with dna evidence. If thats not enough for you the illuminati have the reputation of advertising destructive events before they occur, just like mormons have prophets. Theories of book of mormon translation book of mormon. Proposed book of mormon geographical setting wikipedia.
Criticisms related to view of the hebrews and the book of mormon. Deseret book and farms, 1988, 315, the prophetic book of mormon salt lake city. The new essay begins with this declarative statement. Theories of book of mormon lands in mesoamerica showing 11 of 1 messages. Unconventional book of mormon geography theories mormon. Box 3234 mesquite, nevada 89024 email other informative books about mormons and the lds mormon conspiracy the keystone of mormonism by arza evans click on the mormon book to buy it at summary. Structuring the abridgment of the nephite records, journal of book of mormon studies 15, no.
The nephites made swords of steel, a derivative of iron. A glaring problem with book of mormon geography theories. Dec 12, 2017 since the book of mormons publication in 1830, a number of different theories have been proposed concerning its authorship. Apr 20, 2009 most of you believe that the book of mormon occurred in central america, right. Spaldingrigdon theory proves the book of mormon is false. From time to time, i get an email from george potter. There are differing views on the origin of the book of mormon.
Book of mormon modern expansion theory lds church is true blog. Jan 29, 2019 the article concludes by emphasizing the churchs neutrality on book of mormon geography and quoting president russell m. Wouldnt it be cool to find some archaeological evidence. Spaldingrigdon theory of book of mormon authorship. A readers guide, have attempted to move the discussion away from polemics to an appreciation for the book s. Nelson on the importance the books primary purposeto testify of jesus christ and his gospel.
For those new to the site, you may want to see some of these other theories i mentioned. Others argued for a setting in the american heartland. Themes, theories and evidences for the book of mormon kindle edition by smith, gerald. Would you respond to the theories that the book of mormon.
The theory first appeared in print in the book mormonism unvailed, published in 1834 by e. Disproves lds claims that joseph smith received the book of abraham through revelation and proves that joseph smiths source for his translation was a pagan egyptian text, the book of breathings. Explores the joseph smith papyrus and demonstrates that joseph smiths claim that he had translated the book of abraham from it was a fabrication. Would you respond to the theories that the book of mormon is based on the spaulding manuscript or on ethan smiths view of the hebrews. Church releases statement on book of mormon geography book. The church takes no position on the specific geographic location of book of mormon events in the ancient americas. This book locates everything from the narrow neck, to zarahemla, from cumorah, to the land of promise, bountiful. The evidence for ancient origins, edited by noel b. Though there are several plausible hypotheses regarding the geographic locations of book of mormon events. Debunking 5 myths about the book of mormon lds living. The hill cumorah in ontario county ny is the hill where joseph smith found the golden plates and is the same hill where the civilizations of the nephites cumorah and the jaredites ramah fought their last battles. Its not the movie nor will book of mormon videos give. Reply to pros, cons of book of mormon geography theories.
Following are two of the most well known theories for book of mormon geography. Church releases statement on book of mormon geography. The spaldingrigdon theory of book of mormon authorship is the theory that the book of mormon was plagiarized in part from an unpublished manuscript. Dec 03, 2009 here is what my copy of the book of mormon states. This is a great resource to check whenever you find yourself faced with a challenging topic. The spaldingrigdon theory of book of mormon authorship is the theory that the book of mormon was plagiarized in part from an unpublished manuscript written by solomon spalding. In the years since the book of mormon was published, other naturalistic theories have waxed and waned in popularity, but similar to the early 1830s, joseph smiths intellect theory is today the most accepted naturalistic explanation for the origin of the book of mormon. Its not the movie nor will book of mormon videos give a. Book of mormonauthorship theoriesview of the hebrews. The view of the hebrews theory was examined in detail by b. Gardner, brant a theories of book of mormon translation in the gift and power.
A summary of several theories of book of mormon lands in. Some claim that sidney rigdon authored the book of mormon, and conspired with joseph smith well ahead of time to compose it and start a religion. Those who do not accept the book of mormon as scripture offer many theories about its origin. Meldrum, president, the firm foundation all in all, i found pros, cons of book of mormon geography theories relatively well balanced, although still teetering toward the mesoamerican theories. Theories of book of mormon translation book of mormon central. Blumell, senior historical associate, church historical department historically, the most popular antimormon or nonmormon explanation of the origin of the book of mormon has been that it was based. Theres no dearth of theories of just where the book of mormons new world is located from the great lakes to the heartlands in north america, from various sites in central america or south america and on to a geography theory consisting of the entire western hemisphere. Some critics believe that it was written solely by joseph smith. The heartland model or heartland theory of book of mormon geography states that the book of mormon events primarily occurred in the heartland of north america. Part 3 presents textual studies that demonstrate the plausibility of the book of mormon as an ancient book, and part 4 updates scholars attempts to understand the ancient cultural and. Its been some time since we talked about alternative book of mormon geography theories. Several theories of the origin of the text have emerged, but they lack solid. Both the mesoamerican and the heartland book of mormon geography theories have their strong points and, shall we say, areas that need. In 1991, john sorenson of byu, the dean of book of mormon geography, created a book called the geography of book of mormon events.
Peruvian setting for the book of mormon mormon matters. A readers guide, have attempted to move the discussion away from polemics to an appreciation for the books. Unconventional book of mormon geography theories mormon matters. As early as 1831, eber howe, in his antimormon book mormonism. Dan vogel theories of book of mormon authorship mormon stories february, 2019 book of mormon, church history, joseph smith 7 comments we are excited to welcome back preeminent joseph smith historian dan vogel to mormon stories podcast. He is the author of several books and articles discussing the text of the book of mormon and ancient mesoamerica. It has no connection with the spaulding manuscript. The book of mormon claims that moroni, a prophet, originally wrote the book and that it was translated by joseph smith. Most of you believe that the book of mormon occurred in central america, right. Miraculous origins theories generally accept joseph smiths own account, that he translated an ancient record compiled and abridged by mormon, a precolumbian resident of the western hemisphere. Would you respond to the theories that the book of mormon is based.
The theory first appeared in print in the book mormonism unvailed sic, published in 1834 by e. Themes, theories and evidences for the book of mormon. A radically different book of mormon geography theory. Would you respond to the theories that the book of mormon is. Spaldingrigdon theory of book of mormon authorship wikipedia. Oct 27, 2019 this video discusses all of the main theories critics try and point to for alternative ways the book of mormon could be produced and how these arguments fall apart when the details are explored. Book of mormon geography is one of my favorite topics, and its been a while since i talked about it. The debate over the authenticity of the book of mormon. Nonmormon critics disagree in their opinions as to the origin of the book. Apr 23, 2020 the problem with all theories of the book of mormons authorship that include a prolonged composition period is that there were many witnesses to at least parts of the translation process, all of whom point to a short production period. The people of the book of mormon had herds of animals that could be described as sheep. Joseph smith as the sole author, without intentional assistance, possibly reflecting smiths own life events. Some mormon scholars, like grant hardy, who wrote understanding the book of mormon.
75 290 629 672 948 272 1515 1150 417 1239 1430 1461 1268 401 821 98 1130 73 488 1248 1254 966 974 56 1110 311 94 167 132 418 1058 550 585 287